Get More for Your Money: Comparing Plato’s Closet and Buffalo Exchange

Plato’s Closet offers gently used, name brand clothes and accessories at lower prices than Buffalo Exchange.

Plato’S Closet Vs Buffalo Exchange

Plato’s Closet and Buffalo Exchange are two of the most popular secondhand, pre-worn clothing stores. Both stores feature unique collections of stylish clothes and accessories at an affordable price. The major difference between these two stores lies in their selection, pricing, items traded in-store and online shopping options.

Platos Closet has a wide variety of trendy clothes and accessories for teens and young adults at extremely competitive prices. Plato’s offers items from many renowned brands, as well as departments for sizes 0-15 and separate sections for plus sizes. Additionally, shoppers can find unique jewelry pieces to spice up their ensemble. As a way to keep their selection constantly updated, Platos Closet also buys back items from their customers in exchange for store credit or cash.

On the flipside, Buffalo Exchange is an independent retail store that specializes in vintage clothing. It features a wide variety of high-end vintage fashion pieces at an affordable price. There is no set size offered here, but their inventory depends on donated used items, giving customers the opportunity to find rare gems like designer coats or designer bags well below retail prices. Store credit is offered in exchange for traded items, including accessories such as jewelry and scarves. Unlike Platos Closet, Buffalo Exchange does not offer online shopping options yet – shoppers can only use this service at a physical location nearest them – so make sure to plan your visit!

Selection & Prices

Plato’s Closet and Buffalo Exchange offer a wide selection of pre-owned clothing, shoes, and accessories for both men and women. Plato’s Closet focuses mainly on fashion for teens and young adults, while Buffalo Exchange offers fashion for all ages. The selection at both stores is constantly changing as new items arrive daily. Both stores buy items from customers in exchange for cash or store credit. The selection at Plato’s Closet tends to be more up to date with the latest trends, while Buffalo Exchange offers a more vintage look. Prices at Plato’s Closet are generally lower than those at Buffalo Exchange because the items are typically newer and in better condition.

Quality of Clothing Material

The quality of the clothing material offered by both Plato’s Closet and Buffalo Exchange is generally good. All items have been thoroughly inspected prior to being put up for sale in order to ensure that they meet the quality standards of each store. Plato’s Closet tends to offer more name brand items such as Nike, Adidas, Puma, Hollister, American Eagle, etc., which usually have higher quality material than items found at Buffalo Exchange. On the other hand, some of the vintage pieces found at Buffalo Exchange can be quite unique and high-quality since they are often from past decades when manufacturing standards were higher than they are now.

Store Design

Both Platos Closet and Buffalo Exchange have attractive store designs that make shopping enjoyable. Platos Closet has a bright and modern feel with its clean lines and bright colors that appeal to younger shoppers. Meanwhile, Buffalo Exchange has a more classic aesthetic with its warm colors and vintage decor that appeals to older shoppers looking for unique finds. Both stores offer plenty of space so customers can easily browse through their selection without feeling crowded or overwhelmed by too many options.

Return Policies

Plato’s Closet and Buffalo Exchange each have their own return policies in place in order to ensure customer satisfaction with their purchases. At Plato’s Closet, customers can return items within 14 days of purchase for an exchange or store credit only; no cash refunds are given for returns after 14 days have passed from the date of purchase. At Buffalo Exchange, customers can return items within 30 days for an exchange or refund; however all tags must still be attached to the item in order for it to be accepted as a return item.


Platos Closet has over 500 locations throughout North America while Buffalo Exchange has over 40 locations across the United States and Canada. Each store is independently owned and operated so location availability may vary depending on where you live or are visiting from. However, both stores have an online presence which allows customers access to their products regardless of where they live or travel to.

Customer Reviews

When it comes to customer reviews both Platos Closet and Buffalo Exchange receive overwhelmingly positive feedback from their customers regarding their selection of clothing styles, product quality, prices as well as their friendly customer service staff members who are always ready to help out with any questions or concerns shoppers may have while shopping at either store location or online site. Each store also receives great feedback regarding its cleanliness which is always important when shopping secondhand goods as it ensures that all products purchased will be free from dirt or other potential contaminants that could affect the quality of the item purchased

Rewards Programs with Platos Closet and Buffalo Exchange

Plato’s Closet and Buffalo Exchange both offer rewards programs that help customers save money on their purchases. At Plato’s Closet, customers can join their rewards program to earn points for every dollar spent. These points can then be redeemed for discounts on future purchases. They also offer exclusive rewards such as free shipping and discounts on select items. Buffalo Exchange also has a rewards program where customers can sign up to receive exclusive discounts, free shipping, and bonus offers.

Deals Available at Each Store

Plato’s Closet offers deals like weekly markdowns, BOGO (Buy One Get One) deals, seasonal sales, and special promotions throughout the year. They also offer loyalty points for every purchase made which can be used towards future purchases or exchanged for cashback rewards. Buffalo Exchange has a wide selection of discounted items including end-of-season styles, last-minute sales, and special promotions throughout the year. Customers can also take advantage of their loyalty program which gives members access to exclusive deals and discounts.

Employee Experience between Contenders

The employee experience at Plato’s Closet is known to be friendly and helpful with staff members who are knowledgeable about product selection and trends in fashion. Customers are often given personal attention when shopping at Plato’s Closet stores. Employees are also trained to provide excellent customer service in order to ensure that each shopping experience is enjoyable for everyone involved.
At Buffalo Exchange, employees are known for providing an upbeat atmosphere where customers can find great deals on trendy clothing items in a relaxed environment. Employees are knowledgeable about current fashion trends as well as the products available in store so they can help customers make informed decisions when selecting items for purchase.

Warrants and Guarantees Offered by Each Company

Platos Closets offers a satisfaction guarantee that ensures customers will be happy with their purchase or they will receive a full refund within 14 days of purchase if theyre not satisfied with their purchase. They also offer warranties on certain products such as shoes which provides coverage against defects in material or workmanship for up to one year from the date of purchase. Buffalo Exchanges offers its own satisfaction guarantee which allows customers to return any item purchased within 14 days if theyre not happy with it or if it doesnt fit properly as long as it is still in new condition with original tags attached and hasn’t been worn or washed before returning it back to store or online store where it was purchased from originally. They do not offer any warranties on products sold through their stores but some products may come with manufacturer warranties that apply depending on the product purchased from them

FAQ & Answers

Q: What is the Selection of Plato’s Closet vs Buffalo Exchange?
A: Platos Closet carries a wide selection of gently used clothing, shoes, and accessories for men and women. This brand is focused on teen and young adult fashion. Buffalo Exchange carries vintage clothing, shoes, and accessories for both men and women of all ages.

Q: What are the Prices of Plato’s Closet vs Buffalo Exchange?
A: Prices at Platos Closet vary based on item quality, condition, and style. Generally speaking, prices at Platos Closet are lower than prices at Buffalo Exchange because Platos Closet specializes in gently used items from current trends.

Q: What is the Quality of Clothing Material at Plato’s Closet vs Buffalo Exchange?
A: The quality of clothing material at both stores depends on the individual item. Both stores have a wide range of items that vary in terms of material quality. Generally speaking, the items at Buffalo Exchange tend to be higher-end because they carry vintage pieces as well as current trends.

Q: What are the Return Policies for Plato’s Closet and Buffalo Exchange?
A: Both stores offer return policies that vary depending on individual items. At Platos Closet, customers can return an item within 7 days for store credit or exchange only if it is in its original condition with tags attached. At Buffalo Exchange, customers can return an item within 14 days for store credit or exchange only if it is in its original condition with tags attached.

Q: Where are the Locations of Plato’s Closet and Buffalo Exchange?
A: There are over 500 locations for Platos Closet throughout North America while there are over 30 locations for Buffalo Exchange mainly concentrated in California, Arizona, Colorado, Texas, Oregon, Washington State and New Mexico.

In conclusion, both Plato’s Closet and Buffalo Exchange offer great opportunities to find quality designer clothing at discounted prices. However, Plato’s Closet offers more styles and trends geared toward teens, while Buffalo Exchange is better suited for adults and vintage styles. Ultimately, the decision comes down to personal preference.

Author Profile

Solidarity Project
Solidarity Project
Solidarity Project was founded with a single aim in mind - to provide insights, information, and clarity on a wide range of topics spanning society, business, entertainment, and consumer goods. At its core, Solidarity Project is committed to promoting a culture of mutual understanding, informed decision-making, and intellectual curiosity.

We strive to offer readers an avenue to explore in-depth analysis, conduct thorough research, and seek answers to their burning questions. Whether you're searching for insights on societal trends, business practices, latest entertainment news, or product reviews, we've got you covered. Our commitment lies in providing you with reliable, comprehensive, and up-to-date information that's both transparent and easy to access.